A child is dead near his school, and the mayor of Jerusalem is shocked. Moshe Lion says he trusts the security forces to find the killer. He should be asked a prior question: why is he surprised by what happens in a place his city claims and refuses to govern?
We should be honest about what we don't know. The reporting does not say who shot Qusai al-Julani or why. It does not say whether this was a feud, a criminal killing, or something political. A recording from the camp says houses were burned afterward, which suggests a community that has little faith the state will deliver justice and has started reaching for its own. Anyone claiming certainty about motive is selling something.
What we do know is where this happened. Shuafat refugee camp lies inside Jerusalem's municipal boundary. Israel drew that line after 1967, and Israel's government calls the city its undivided capital. The people of the camp are, for the most part, Jerusalem residents who are supposed to receive what residents receive. But the separation barrier cuts the camp off from the rest of the city. Services are thin, building is chaotic, and policing is notoriously sparse. Criminal gangs and feuds fill that vacuum. When the state is present, it often shows up in the form of raids, not patrol cars.
The defense is easy to predict. If this was Palestinians killing a Palestinian child, the argument goes, it is a tragedy but not a policy failure. That has it backwards. Sovereignty is not a trophy. Claiming a territory means accepting the duty to protect everyone in it, including the people you would rather not have annexed. A government that collects municipal taxes, controls the checkpoints, and sets the boundaries cannot treat the resulting lawlessness as an unfortunate local custom. Israel chose to hold this land and chose to build the wall around it. The vacuum is a consequence of those choices.
The school detail matters too. For years, East Jerusalem has been short of classrooms, and thousands of children have lacked a place in the public system. UNRWA has filled part of that gap in the camp. Israel has spent the past two years trying to shut those schools down without a credible plan to replace them. You can have views about UNRWA's flaws. But you do not get to dismantle the institutions that educate children and then act surprised when children have fewer safe places to be.
The mayor's statement is the standard script: shock, condolences, faith in the security services. But the security services are the problem as much as the solution. Their reputation in the camp is as an occupying force that appears for punishment and vanishes when a family needs a detective. A murder investigation requires witnesses, and witnesses require trust. Trust cannot be summoned by a press release in a neighborhood where the state has spent decades demonstrating that it is not on your side.
If Jerusalem's leaders want to prove that a child in Shuafat matters as much as a child in Rehavia, the proof is not a statement. It is a real investigation, a visible and accountable police presence, and a school system that includes these children. It is also a restraint on the reprisal and arson that turn one death into a spiral. Anything less is grief as public relations.
Qusai al-Julani was a child. Whoever killed him owes an answer, and so does the city that says he was its own.


