Pay attention to the word "retaliation." Vladimir Putin vowed to punish Ukraine for attacking the Crimean Bridge, and on Friday his ballistic missiles hit three bridges across the Dnipro in a capital city of millions. The Defense Ministry called it a strike on "transport infrastructure." In Kyiv, six people were dead, parts of the city had no power, and crossings that residents rely on to get around the city were closed or restricted. Drones also hit apartment blocks in Dnipropetrovsk, a hospital in Kharkiv and a tram in Zaporizhzhia.
The moral logic of "retaliation" collapses on contact with the facts. The Crimean Bridge connects Russia to territory it seized by force in 2014, and it carries military supplies for an occupation that violates the U.N. Charter. Kyiv's bridges are crossings at the heart of a capital city, not a supply line to an occupied peninsula. Russia's own pretext shows the strategy: when it cannot win on the battlefield, it makes civilian life as miserable, frightening and dark as possible. Attacking a hospital and a tram is the point of the exercise, not collateral damage.
This is where the Left should be unambiguous. We spent decades arguing that sovereignty cannot be erased by the powerful, that civilians are not bargaining chips, and that empires do not get to redraw maps with artillery. If those principles mean anything, they apply when the aggressor is Moscow. Anti-imperialism with a carve-out for imperialists we find geopolitically convenient is not a principle. It is a mood.
I say this knowing that a faction of the Left, and a louder one online, treats Ukraine mainly as a vehicle for American arms makers and Washington's hawks. The critique of the defense industry's profits is fair. But the logic of "just negotiate" does not survive a week like this. Every time Ukrainians have been told to accept a freeze, Russia has used the pause to regroup. A peace that leaves Putin holding what he took, and Ukraine without security guarantees, is not peace. It is an intermission before the next bridge, the next hospital, the next tram.
The harder question is aimed at Western governments, including the one in Washington. Ballistic missiles are hard to stop. Interceptors for them are scarce and expensive, and Ukrainian officials have been begging for more for years. Aid has been held up by domestic political theater, by Republican brinkmanship in Congress and by a White House that treats the war as an item in a transactional negotiation. Democrats are not blameless either. Years of cautious, incremental escalation management taught Moscow that red lines were negotiable, and that every new weapon system would arrive late. Delay has a body count. It is counted in Kyiv this weekend.
There is also a plain labor and public-goods story here that rarely makes the headlines. The people repairing power lines under threat of a second strike, running the trams, staffing the Kharkiv hospital and rebuilding the spans are public workers doing essential work in conditions that would shut down any other workplace on earth. Ukrainian unions have said for years that the country's reconstruction should not be a fire sale to foreign investors. Supporting Ukraine means supporting those workers and the public institutions they keep alive.
None of this requires romanticizing Kyiv's government or pretending the war has simple endings. It requires a refusal to accept the lie at the center of Moscow's rhetoric: that bombing a city's bridges is a proportionate answer to hitting a military supply line. The Left's job is to say what this is, a campaign against civilians, and to demand that the democracies able to help stop it actually do so, before the next "retaliation" is announced.


