A $600 million trade relationship is a rounding error. Peru exports many times that to China alone, and Hong Kong's chief executive knows it. So the point of John Lee's sit-down with Peru's president in Shenzhen was never the money. It was the photograph: a man sanctioned by Washington for his role in dismantling Hong Kong's civil liberties, treated as a normal head of government by a Latin American president and Singapore's prime minister, at a summit hosted by Beijing.
That should bother anyone who takes rights seriously. Lee was Hong Kong's security chief when the 2020 national security law was imposed, and the city's press, opposition and civil society have been hollowed out since. Jimmy Lai, a 78-year-old publisher, has sat in custody since 2020. Hong Kong is now sold abroad as a gateway, a connector and a hub, and the pitch works because partners agree not to look at what happened to the people who once made the city's freedoms real. Singapore thanking Lee, or Lee thanking Singapore, for backing Hong Kong's entry into the RCEP bloc is the same transaction on a larger scale: access in exchange for silence.
But the Left should resist the easy conclusion that Peru's president is simply a dupe or a villain. He is a head of state in a poor, unstable country, and China has become Peru's largest trading partner. Beijing financed the giant Chancay port, which is rewriting South American logistics. Peru did not choose this over a better offer from Washington. There was no offer.
That is the part of the story American politicians would rather skip. Washington walked away from the Trans-Pacific Partnership, then spent years treating tariffs as a foreign policy and "trade deal" as a synonym for "concession." Today's administration threatens allies and bullies partners, then expresses shock when they turn up in Shenzhen. You cannot lecture Lima about dependence on China while offering Lima nothing but tariffs and a lecture. The vacuum is bipartisan, but the current White House has widened it with enthusiasm.
So the Left has two jobs, and both are uncomfortable. The first is to refuse the cynicism that says human rights are a luxury item, to be dropped whenever commerce calls. Hong Kong's repression is not a Western talking point. It is the lived reality of people who were arrested for signs, songs and newspapers. A trading system that rewards that, and asks nothing of it, is a system built for the powerful.
The second job is to stop pretending that the alternative is the old American-led order, which was not a moral crusade either. Trade agreements written in Washington spent decades protecting investors and pharmaceutical patents while treating labor and environmental chapters as decoration. If we want Peru to have something better than Beijing's no-questions-asked deal, we have to offer something actually better: financing without strings that gut public services, enforceable labor standards, and protections for the Indigenous and rural communities that live beside the mines and ports. Peruvians know what extraction looks like. Under the last government, security forces killed dozens of protesters, mostly in the poor, Indigenous south. Cheerful talk of "jobs and living standards" tells us nothing about who gets those jobs and who gets the tailings.
The handshake in Shenzhen is a small event, which is why it matters. This is how influence is built: not through dramatic confrontation, but through a thousand routine meetings where one side shows up and the other doesn't. The answer is not to boycott Beijing's summits and call it principle. It is to show up with a trade agenda that treats workers and rights as terms of the deal, not afterthoughts. Until then, Lee will keep collecting his photographs.


