US, China and Russia leaders scheduled for summit in China

Illustration for: US, China and Russia leaders scheduled for summit in China
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin are scheduled to hold a three-way summit on Thursday in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting.

Putin and Trump are also scheduled to hold separate bilateral talks on Thursday. The two leaders greeted each other before a welcome dinner on Wednesday.

A South Korean presidential official said Seoul is watching how issues affecting the Korean Peninsula might be addressed at the three-way meeting. South Korea is not participating in the talks, the official said, adding that the government is taking steps to protect its interests.

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

Let me say something that will annoy some of my own side: talking to Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin is not the scandal. The Left has long believed that nuclear-armed powers should talk, and that reflexive Cold War theater gets people killed. If a three-way meeting in Shenzhen reduced the risk of war, I would applaud it.

But look at who is in the room and who is not. Washington, Beijing and Moscow are sitting down together while South Korea, a treaty ally with 28,000 American troops on its soil and a nuclear-armed neighbor to the north, is reduced to "watching" and "taking steps to protect its interests." That is the diplomatic language of a government that fears it will read about its own future in the news. Nothing in the reporting suggests Ukraine has a seat either, though Putin's war is the reason his presence at a summit with an American president is remarkable at all.

This is not diplomacy in the sense we on the Left usually defend, which is patient, institutional, multilateral and aimed at lowering the cost of conflict for ordinary people. It looks like the old great-power habit of deciding things among the big three and informing everyone else afterward. Call it spheres of influence with better catering.

The tell is the way Trump has governed alliances. He treats them as protection rackets, with allies billed for the privilege of being defended. Having taught Seoul, Tokyo and Europe that American commitments are negotiable, he now shows up to a table with the two leaders most eager to see those commitments dissolve. Why would Xi not want to talk about the Korean Peninsula without Seoul present? Why would Putin not enjoy a photograph that tells the world his invasion has cost him nothing in standing? Both men are getting what they wanted. The question is what the United States is getting, and the answer so far is a dinner and a handshake.

Republicans spent years calling any engagement with adversaries appeasement. Barack Obama's Iran deal, negotiated with allies, inspections and Congress in the loop, was treated as national betrayal. Now a president who personalizes foreign policy goes to China to deal with Putin and Xi, and the same voices call it strength. The principle was never about adversaries. It was about whose hands were on the pen.

The Left should not fall into the opposite trap and treat every Trump meeting as treason. That is lazy, and it is how Democrats end up defending the foreign policy establishment's worst instincts. Our test should be simple and consistent: who decides, who is represented, and who pays?

On that test, this summit is troubling. Nobody has voted for a new arrangement among the three powers. Congress has no visible role. Allies are bystanders. And the people with the most to lose, Koreans living within artillery range, Ukrainians under bombardment, and Taiwanese watching what the big powers consider tradable, have no one advocating for them in the room. The administration has spent a year dismantling the aid programs, diplomatic capacity and alliance trust that give American diplomacy leverage. Then it asks us to believe the president's personal charm will substitute.

It will not. Personal rapport between strongmen is cheap and reversible, while institutions, treaties and verification regimes are what outlast a bad mood. If Trump comes home with nothing that Seoul, Kyiv or Congress can examine and hold him to, then this was not statecraft. It was a photo op for autocrats, with ordinary people left to cover the bill.

Democrats should demand a plain accounting after Thursday. What was discussed about Korea? What was offered on Ukraine? What was promised, and by whom? A president who negotiates the security of other nations without them owes the public answers.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed