Taiwan opposition lawmakers seek thesis inquiry into Keelung mayoral candidate

Illustration for: Taiwan opposition lawmakers seek thesis inquiry into Keelung mayoral candidate
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

Taiwan’s Kuomintang legislative caucus has called on National Taiwan Ocean University to investigate the master’s thesis of Tung Tzu-wei, the Democratic Progressive Party’s candidate for mayor of Keelung.

At a press conference, the caucus alleged that Tung plagiarized research from mainland China. Caucus secretary-general Hsu Yu-chen said a text comparison found a 42% similarity rate, including 14.8% matching multiple Chinese research papers.

Tung’s campaign office said an originality check showed a 27% similarity rate, below the 30% standard currently used by some university departments. It said academic ethics should be assessed through professional review rather than accusations.

The university said it would look into the matter and handle it under its administrative procedures and regulations.

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

Let's start with what is not in dispute. Plagiarism is plagiarism, and a person who wants to run a city should not have lifted other people's work. If Tung Tzu-wei's thesis contains uncredited copying, the Democratic Progressive Party should say so and act accordingly, as it did in 2022, when Lin Chih-chien withdrew from the Taoyuan race over his own thesis scandal. That precedent is the party's best credential on this issue. It is also the standard the DPP now has to hold itself to.

But look at what the Kuomintang caucus actually delivered: a press conference and a number. A 42% "similarity rate," with 14.8% attributed to Chinese research papers, produced by the accusers themselves, with no disclosed method and no indication of what was excluded. Similarity software flags everything it finds: quotations, bibliographies, stock methodological phrasing, standard definitions. It produces a lead for a human reviewer to examine. It does not produce a verdict. Tung's office reports 27% on its own check. Two scores from two different setups tell us only that the software is not a judge.

The campaign's defense is also thinner than it sounds. Falling under the 30% line some departments use is not an acquittal. That line is an administrative screen, not a definition of honesty. A thesis can sit at 5% and still contain one stolen chapter, or sit at 35% and be clean. The only question that matters is whether passages were copied without attribution. Tung should publish the thesis, welcome the review, and answer for any passage that fails the test. "Let the professionals decide" works only if you actually mean it.

Then there is the "mainland China" framing, which is doing more work than the arithmetic. Why does the source's nationality matter? Copying from a Taiwanese paper is exactly as dishonest as copying from a Chinese one, and citing Chinese scholarship honestly is ordinary research. Cross-strait scholarship is a legitimate field, and much of the relevant literature is written in Chinese on the other side of the Strait. The caucus is reaching for a patriotic frisson, hinting at something disloyal beyond the academic offense. It is rich coming from a party whose leaders keep traveling to Beijing-friendly forums and whose own most prominent figures have spent years explaining why engagement with the Chinese Communist Party is just pragmatism. The KMT cannot treat Chinese sources as normal when it suits its diplomacy and as a smear when it suits its campaign.

The timing tells its own story. Local elections are coming, and a degree dispute is cheap, vivid, and easy to circulate. Keelung is a weathered port city with real problems: an aging population, a hollowed-out harbor economy, relentless flooding, and a commute to Taipei that defines working life. A campaign about those things would require the KMT to defend its record. A campaign about a footnote requires only a spreadsheet.

This pattern wears down public institutions. National Taiwan Ocean University is a public university, and it now has to adjudicate a candidate's thesis in the middle of an election, with every faction watching. That pressure runs in all directions. Academic review should be insulated from both the accusers' timelines and the candidate's party. Politicians on both sides ought to commit to the same rule: no verdicts before the committee reports, and no ignoring the committee when it does.

The DPP has no reason to flinch from this. If the review clears Tung, the KMT will have spent its credibility on a number it could not defend. If it does not, the party must act without excuses, because its claim to be the cleaner, more accountable camp is worth more than one mayoral race in Keelung. Integrity that applies only when it is convenient is just branding. Demanding the real process, from the university and from ourselves, is how the Left proves it is not.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed