Read the story closely and notice who is consulted. The head of a regional council gets to ask for safety measures and discussions. The defense minister personally reassures the residents of Netiv HaAsara that Erez will not open to goods. Southern Command frets about Palestinian drivers touching roads that, until now, only soldiers used. Nobody in this account speaks for the two million people the trucks are meant to reach.
That omission is the story. Humanitarian aid to Gaza is still managed as a problem of Israeli domestic comfort, with the starving as a secondary consideration.
Let me be fair to the residents. Netiv HaAsara sits a few hundred meters from the fence. On October 7, Hamas gunmen came through communities like it, and anyone who waves away those families' fear of trucks and strangers on their roads has not been listening. Screening is not inherently sinister, and Hamas has stolen and taxed aid. Those are real arguments, and they deserve better than slogans.
But they answer a narrower question than the one that matters. Nobody disputes that cargo can be inspected. The question is why the architecture of inspection keeps growing while the people it is supposed to serve keep running short. Every added checkpoint, route restriction, and rule on who may drive where is a decision, and each one lengthens the time between a truck leaving a warehouse and a child receiving a meal. Kerem Shalom is already a bottleneck. Adding Erez as a screening stop before sending trucks back to Kerem Shalom is not generosity. It is another station on an obstacle course, presented as progress.
The pattern deserves bluntness. Under the ceasefire, mediators and the UN spoke of hundreds of trucks a day. Aid agencies have repeatedly said the flow falls short of what is needed, while Israel disputes their numbers and says it is meeting its obligations. Whoever is right on the count, the mechanism is the same. Israel controls the gates, the lists, the permitted items, and the routes, and so controls the hunger. That is a form of power, and under the Fourth Geneva Convention it brings obligations. The International Court of Justice said last year that Israel must facilitate relief, including through the UN. An occupying power cannot hold the keys and then cite the lock as an excuse.
It is telling that Katz's promise to residents carried more weight than any promise to Gaza's hungry. Netiv HaAsara's fears are treated as a fixed constraint, while Gaza's starvation is treated as a variable to be optimized around them. Israeli officials could have said that the security of border communities and the survival of Gaza's civilians are both obligations of the state. Instead the burden is passed down the chain to whoever has the least power to object.
The Left should also look at itself. Too many Democrats treat Gaza aid as a matter for statements of concern and carefully worded letters. The United States supplies the weapons, the diplomatic cover, and a great deal of the leverage. A government that can persuade Israel to open a new screening point can insist that the screening be fast, that the routes be many, and that the food arrive. Asking is not the same as conditioning, and Washington has mostly asked.
Security and sufficiency are not opposites. Scanning technology exists, and so do third-party monitors, pre-clearance, and more crossings. What does not exist is the political will to make the hungry the first priority rather than the last. Until it does, every announcement of a new screening step should be read for what it is: a sign that the process is working as designed, which is not the same as working for the people it claims to serve.


