Fed’s Warsh outlines three scenarios for AI’s effect on U.S. economy

Illustration for: Fed’s Warsh outlines three scenarios for AI’s effect on U.S. economy
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

The Federal Reserve’s Kevin Warsh has outlined three scenarios for how artificial intelligence could affect the U.S. economy, ranging from stronger growth to labor-market disruption or a slowdown.

Warsh said technological advances could increase economic growth while employment remains near full capacity. He also cautioned that automation could displace workers and raise unemployment.

In a third scenario, he said, returns on investment and market valuations could fall after heavy spending, slowing the economy and increasing unemployment without delivering the expected productivity gains.

Warsh also said the United States could not become a superpower without what he called “super intelligence.”

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

Kevin Warsh said the part the Federal Reserve usually smothers in scenarios. The United States, he argued, cannot be a superpower without what he called “super intelligence.” The three paths he sketched — growth with employment still near full capacity, automation that displaces workers and lifts unemployment, or a spending bust that slows the economy without the productivity that was supposed to justify it — are not a seminar. They are a description of how a great power keeps its edge or talks itself out of it.

The fashionable response is to treat artificial intelligence as a domestic fairness problem. Manage the transition. Fund the reskilling. Sue the firms that got there first. Wait for the historical assurance that technology always creates jobs. That assurance is not nothing. The strongest argument against panic is the actual record of industrial economies: occupations die, living standards rise, and the societies that tried to freeze the machine in place did not save their workers. They saved their rivals’ market share. Anyone who skips that record is not being cautious. They are advertising a preference for managed decline.

But the growth scenario Warsh put first is not a gift from the model. It is a construction project. Data centers do not run on press releases. They run on electricity, permits, chips, capital, and people who can build the physical plant. The contemporary American Right’s useful insight here is unromantic: abundance is a policy choice, and so is scarcity. A country that cannot permit a power line or a plant on a human timescale will not get the sunny scenario. It will get the lecture about transitions, delivered from institutions that never had to pour the concrete.

The displacement scenario should not be euphemized, and it should not be surrendered to. Automation can idle workers. Counties that already lost the last good job do not need a white paper explaining that aggregate employment might recover by the next decade. They need a political class that stops confusing “the economy” with the credentialed occupations most frightened of a chatbot. The wrong answer is to slow American deployment until every disrupted role has been assigned a new narrative. Hobbling the domestic industry does not protect American labor. It protects the competitor that will deploy anyway — above all China — and then sends the social bill home. The harder conservative claim is that the jobs worth fighting for sit in the stack around the model: power, construction, manufacturing, logistics, defense. If AI is only a windfall for a handful of equity holders and a threat to everyone else, the politics will turn on it, and they should.

That is also why the third scenario matters, and why it should make the Fed modest rather than oracular. Heavy spending, falling returns, valuations that crack, unemployment up, productivity missing. We have seen this movie without a single large language model. Cheap money and a compelling story can outrun cash flow. The institution that spent years discovering inflation late is not thereby qualified to midwife the next general-purpose technology by speechmaking. If the capex boom can become a bust, the implication is honest prices, skepticism of subsidy fashion, and less reverence for concentrated narrative — not a new planning mandate for central bankers.

A serious opponent does not deny any of this by being cartoonishly anti-market. Gains may pool first in capital and in the workers whose skills complement the models. Fraud, security failures, and corporate concentration are real. A Right that answers every objection with “number go up” will earn the backlash when the second or third scenario lands in a state that decides elections. The distinction is the remedy. Public accountability for fraud and for firms that capture the state is not the same thing as a permission regime that hands the lead to Beijing while calling the delay ethics.

China is not waiting on three scenarios. It is accumulating compute, power, talent, and military application, and it will tolerate domestic disruption that democratic politicians will be tempted to forbid by statute. Deterrence now includes whether American industry sets the pace. Warsh’s line about super intelligence is easy to mock if you think superpower status is a tone of voice. It is a capability. The scenario that arrives will be shaped by whether we build the first, tell the truth about the second, and refuse to inflate the third. Pretending the choice is someone else’s is not prudence. It is unilateral disarmament with cleaner language.

How it may affect me

If your work is routine and clerical, treat displacement as a planning fact: “the economy will adjust” is not your timeline. If you invest, the third scenario is already the valuation argument — heavy AI spending can disappoint before productivity shows up in earnings. The lever that reaches households is power. Data-center buildout and permitting delays will show up in electricity prices and in whether the growth scenario is even physically possible where you live.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed