Salvadoran troops confront gangs in Haiti as residents demonstrate

Illustration for: Salvadoran troops confront gangs in Haiti as residents demonstrate
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

Salvadoran troops have deployed to Haiti to confront armed gangs in the capital, Port-au-Prince, where residents have demonstrated in support of the Salvadoran intervention.

Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele said his country’s Council of Ministers approved a bilateral cooperation agreement with Haiti.

Conflict-monitoring organization ACLED said more than 100 people, including at least 26 civilians, were killed amid what it described as indiscriminate crackdowns in residential areas. It said attacks targeting gangs increased by 46% in the 21 days following the deployment.

Diego Daín, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, said Salvadoran troops do not remain in areas after raids, allowing gangs to return and threaten residents.

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

When people in Port-au-Prince march in support of foreign soldiers, the first duty of anyone on the Left is to shut up and listen. These are not dupes of a Central American strongman's social media operation. They are people who have spent years hostage to gangs that rape, burn neighborhoods, and tax the price of a bag of rice. They want someone, anyone, to make it stop. Sneering at that wish from a safe distance is a luxury, and a contemptible one.

But listening to the demand is not the same as endorsing the product being sold. The numbers in this story are the product review. ACLED counts more than 100 dead, at least 26 of them civilians, in what it calls indiscriminate crackdowns in residential areas. Attacks targeting gangs rose 46 percent in three weeks. And Diego Daín of the International Crisis Group notes that the Salvadoran troops don't stay after their raids, so the gangs come back and punish the neighbors who cheered. A raid with no occupation of the ground afterward is not security. It is a provocation with a press office.

That is the dirty secret of the so-called Bukele model. Its fans treat it as a technique that can be exported like a software update. In El Salvador it rested on conditions Haiti doesn't have: a functioning state that already controlled its territory, a police force that could hold neighborhoods, and a prison system able to swallow tens of thousands of people. It also rested on the suspension of due process. Salvadorans have been jailed in mass sweeps, with rights groups documenting arbitrary detention, deaths in custody, and torture allegations. Haiti has no such state to inherit the aftermath. It has no elected president and no sitting senators. It has a transitional authority of dubious legitimacy and a police force outgunned by the people it is supposed to arrest. Importing the repression without the state means importing only the killing.

The real scandal isn't Bukele's opportunism. Opportunism is what strongmen do. The scandal is that Haitians were left with nobody else to cheer for.

For years, wealthy governments treated Haiti as a rolling humanitarian photo-op. The United States and its allies backed unelected leaders because they were convenient, and the 2021 assassination of Jovenel Moïse left a vacuum they never tried seriously to fill. The Kenyan-led mission was starved of money, equipment, and personnel, then discussed as though its failure were a Haitian character flaw. Meanwhile the guns keep arriving, much of it traced to weapons trafficking out of the United States, a supply line Washington has been remarkably relaxed about while lecturing Haiti on order. Now that a tiny country's populist president offers troops and a brand, the same governments can say they've done something while paying nothing. Outsourcing is cheap, and the bill arrives in Haitian bodies.

The Left should say plainly what a real answer looks like, because "no intervention" is not one. It looks like a force that holds neighborhoods after clearing them, with vetted police, courts, and civilian oversight so that a teenager in the wrong alley isn't a statistic in somebody's victory lap. It means choking off arms and money to the gangs, including the traffickers and the local elites who have made peace with them. It means a political path back to elections, so that security has a legitimate Haitian government to hand over to. And it means funding all of that at the scale we spend on things the powerful actually care about.

Haitians asked for protection. They are being offered a raid and a hashtag. Applause in the street is a measure of how desperate they are, not proof that anyone has come with a plan.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed