US, Chinese and Russian leaders meet for talks

Illustration for: US, Chinese and Russian leaders meet for talks
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

The leaders of the United States, China and Russia met for talks in China. US President Donald Trump said the meeting took place during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen.

Trump said the three leaders discussed preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. He also said he wanted an enduring agreement that would bar Iran from obtaining them.

Observers said the leaders appeared to have discussed the Korean Peninsula in broad terms. They noted significant differences over North Korea’s nuclear program.

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

Let me say the part that will annoy some of my friends: talking is better than not talking. The Left that cheered the Iran deal in 2015 has no business sneering at diplomacy because Donald Trump is the one doing it. If three nuclear-armed powers can reduce the odds of a proliferation crisis, good.

But look at what Trump actually brought home from Shenzhen: a claim. By his account, the three leaders discussed keeping Iran from getting a nuclear weapon, and he wants an "enduring" agreement. Enduring. That word should stick in the throat of anyone who remembers that an enduring agreement existed, and he shredded it.

The 2015 nuclear deal capped Iran's enrichment, shipped out its stockpile and put inspectors in its facilities. The IAEA repeatedly certified that Iran was complying. Trump walked away in 2018 anyway, to please hawks and to undo anything with Obama's name on it. Iran then enriched to levels it had never reached under the deal. Last year the U.S. bombed its nuclear sites, and Trump declared them obliterated. Now he wants a durable settlement. He is asking for a lasting peace after personally demolishing the last one.

The company matters, too. Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin did not come to Shenzhen to help Washington enforce nonproliferation out of the goodness of their hearts. Each has his own interests in Iran, and neither has reason to give Trump a win for free. Putin's Russia has deepened its military partnership with North Korea, the very proliferator the observers say the leaders could not agree on. Moscow has reportedly taken North Korean troops and munitions for its war in Ukraine, and it gets a shield against pressure at the UN in return. You cannot credibly ask Russia to help contain nuclear outlaws while it is paying one of them in the currency that keeps its program alive.

Then there is what the account leaves out. Ukraine is nowhere in the story. Neither are the allies who live next door to these powers: Seoul, Tokyo, Taipei, Kyiv and Europe's capitals. When great powers talk about the Korean Peninsula "in broad terms" without the Koreans in the room, that is not diplomacy. It is a spheres-of-influence seminar, and small countries are the menu.

This is the pattern of Trump's foreign policy. It runs on personal chemistry, summit theater and announcements, with no process behind it. He met Kim Jong Un three times, produced handshakes and photographs, and North Korea's arsenal has only grown. Real arms control is dull. It needs verification, sequencing, sanctions relief that can be given and taken back, allied buy-in and, yes, congressional involvement. The Iran deal had all of that. What Trump offers is a president who treats the world as a negotiation between strongmen, with himself as the best dealmaker among them.

The Democratic response should not be hawkish reflex, and it should not be pretending that Trump never talks to adversaries. It should be sharper. Show us the text. Show us the inspections. Show us what Russia and China are being asked to give, and what they are being promised. Explain why Ukraine, whose children Putin stands accused of deporting under an ICC warrant, did not make the readout. And explain why anyone should believe this president's "enduring" promises after he proved that American signatures last only until the next election.

A photo of three men at a table is not a nonproliferation regime. The Left should be the first to demand the difference.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed