Every incumbent in the world claims to have kept her promises. Hsinchu Mayor Kao Hung-an at least brought a number: more than 85 percent fulfilled. It is a nice number, and it tells voters almost nothing.
The mayor wrote the promises, chose the ones worth keeping, and now grades her own exam. A pledge to "study" something and a pledge to build something both count toward the score. Voters should ask what the missing 15 percent was, and whether it was the hard part.
Then there is the headline brag: more than NT$10 billion in public debt repaid. Debt repayment polls well because it sounds like household virtue. But a city is not a household, and Hsinchu is not an ordinary city. It sits beside the science park and the semiconductor supply chain that make Taiwan rich. It is a place where capital piles up, and the people who service that wealth, such as teachers, clerks, care workers and younger families, are told to admire a clean balance sheet while rents and home prices climb out of reach.
The Left's question is what the repayment cost. Every NT$10 billion sent to creditors is NT$10 billion not spent on public childcare, social housing, or the senior care that an aging Taiwan needs. Sometimes paying down debt is prudent. But a mayor who treats it as the main measure of success has chosen austerity and presented the choice as neutral accounting.
School construction is the stronger half of her record. Renovating 24 buildings at 18 schools is the kind of boring public investment that makes a city livable, and she should get credit for it. But the same speech shows the pattern of campaign season. Benefits for older residents and families are announced, but the rally coverage gives no price, no funding source, and no sign of whether they are permanent programs or pre-election sweeteners. A one-time handout in an election year is a gift. A durable service is a right. Voters deserve to know which one they are being offered.
The new proposals raise the same question. A women's life center in every district could be a real public good, a place for care, counseling, and community services that women have long been expected to improvise for themselves. Or it could be a ribbon-cutting with a nice sign and a thin budget. An arena in the same breath is even more telling. Arenas are visible and photogenic, and they are the sort of thing that looks like progress on a flyer. Whether they serve ordinary residents depends on who runs them, who pays, and whether they crowd out less glamorous needs.
The presence of a former Taoyuan magistrate and a sitting legislator on the stage is also a reminder that this is a coalition of ambitions as much as a platform. Taiwan's politics is crowded with figures who change banners and alliances while insisting they are above ideology. Voters are entitled to ask what, beyond competence and a good smile, ties them to working people.
None of this means Kao should lose. It means the people of Hsinchu should refuse the easy frame of a report card, and the opposition, whoever it is, should do more than copy it. The contest should not be about who balances the books more tidily. It should be about who will use this city's extraordinary wealth to make life affordable for those who do not own a share of the chip boom. Debt repaid is a number. Housing built, children cared for, and elders supported are a city. Voters should demand the second kind of accounting.


