EU considers entry ban for Russian military personnel

Illustration for: EU considers entry ban for Russian military personnel
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

The European Union is considering an entry ban on Russian military personnel who took part in the war against Ukraine as part of its upcoming 22nd sanctions package against Russia.

EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said European intelligence agencies could obtain personal data on Russian military personnel.

Russia’s permanent mission to the EU questioned whether gathering military records would comply with the bloc’s privacy rules. Russian lawmaker and retired general Vladimir Shamanov also rejected Kallas’ remarks.

Same Facts. Different Perspectives.

Two AI models. Two viewpoints. One factual foundation.

Moscow's complaint that the EU might violate its privacy rules by collecting data on Russian soldiers is the kind of line that should embarrass whoever wrote it. A state that sent hundreds of thousands of men across a border to shell apartment blocks, and that is accused of deporting Ukrainian children, now invokes data protection. Nobody should take lessons in legal scruple from the Russian mission to the EU, or from a retired general in the Duma who waves away the question.

But the bad faith of the objector doesn't make the objection worthless. The Left has spent a decade arguing that privacy and due process are what stand between ordinary people and the security state, and we don't get to suspend that argument because the target is unsympathetic. Kaja Kallas says European intelligence services could obtain personal data on Russian military personnel. Fine. The question is what happens next. Who goes on the list, on what evidence, and can anyone get off it?

Start with the principle, which is sound. People who took part in atrocities in Ukraine should not be vacationing in Lisbon or buying property in Cyprus while the families of their victims dig through rubble. Accountability is not optional. The UN's investigators have documented war crimes by Russian forces, and the ICC has issued warrants. A travel ban aimed at the people who actually did this is defensible.

But "took part in the war" is not a legal category. It covers a commander who ordered the torture of prisoners in Izium, and it covers a conscript from a poor region who was handed a rifle and told his contract was not up for discussion. Russia's army is heavily recruited from its poorest areas, through cash bonuses, debt pressure and prison release. Treating all of them as one hostile mass is collective punishment. It is also bad strategy. The men Europe most wants to peel away from this war are the ones who run, desert or refuse, and a blanket ban tells them there is no road out.

So the line has to be drawn clearly. The ban should be tied to individual evidence of involvement in violations of the laws of war, with a real route to challenge a listing. Deserters, objectors and those fleeing mobilisation need explicit protection and access to asylum. A sanction that catches a defector at the border is a sanction that serves Putin.

Then there is the question the Brussels communiqué culture avoids. This is the 22nd package. After twenty-one rounds, the war continues, and an entry ban is the cheapest tool in the box. It costs European governments nothing, offends no powerful lobby, and produces a satisfying headline. Compare that with what has proven hard: shutting down the shadow fleet that keeps oil revenue flowing, closing the third-country transshipment routes that supply Russia's war industry, and using immobilised Russian state assets to fund Ukraine's defence and reconstruction rather than leaving them as a bargaining chip. Every month Europe fiddles with symbolic measures while its energy and finance sectors drag their feet is a month Ukrainian cities are bombed.

If Europe wants to be taken seriously, it should do the harder version of accountability. Fund investigators, build war-crimes files, and use universal jurisdiction so that a soldier who tortured civilians faces a courtroom, not just a visa refusal. A stamp in a passport is not justice.

Support the ban, then, but insist it be made of law rather than mood. The strength of the case against Russia's war is that it rests on rules Russia broke. Europe should not abandon those rules, due process included, the moment they become inconvenient to enforce.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed