Look at the guest list for the future of Europe's largest war in eighty years. A summit of Washington, Beijing and Moscow. Two of Donald Trump's personal emissaries, a real estate developer and his son-in-law, taking meetings in Berlin. And Europe, the continent actually being fought over, announcing a joint delegation to the next round of talks, only to be told by the Kremlin that it hasn't been approved and will be considered once Moscow receives "substantive proposals."
Read that last part again. Russia is deciding whether Europe may attend a negotiation about Europe's security. That isn't diplomacy. It's a spheres-of-influence carve-up with the paperwork done in advance.
The Left has its own reasons to be furious, and they aren't the ones the right-wing press will assume. Nobody serious on the American or European left wanted this war to grind on forever, and nobody should pretend otherwise. Ending it is a moral good. But the question that matters is the one we ask of any deal struck among the powerful: who pays, and who was in the room? A settlement that rewards an invasion teaches every strongman with a map and a grievance that the method works. Ukrainians would pay first. Taiwanese, Moldovans and Baltic citizens would be next in line.
Then there is the question of who is brokering it. Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are not career diplomats steeped in the region's history or bound by any duty to Congress or the public. Kushner's investment firm was bankrolled largely by Saudi sovereign wealth, and the idea that the Trump circle sees Ukraine's future partly as a deal flow problem, reconstruction contracts, minerals and sanctions relief, isn't paranoia. It's how this administration has described its own interests. When the people drafting a peace could profit from its terms, "security guarantees" deserves a hard look at who wrote the fine print.
This is where the Left must also turn on its own side. Europe's centre-left governments, including Britain's, have spent three years issuing ringing statements while hesitating over the money, the weapons and the frozen Russian assets that would give those statements weight. Andy Burnham says Europe must "make its position clear." Fine. But positions don't deter tanks. A seat at the table is bought with leverage, and Europe has been shopping for leverage on credit, hoping Washington would cover the bill. That was always a bet on the reliability of an American electorate that has now twice chosen Trump. Berlin is where the bill arrives.
If Europe wants more than a spectator's seat, it needs to stop asking and start acting. It should commit to financing Ukraine's defense on a multi-year basis, free of American permission. It should use the immobilized Russian assets rather than guard them as a bargaining chip nobody dares to spend. And it should insist that any guarantee be binding and ratified by legislatures, not a handshake that evaporates with the next administration. A guarantee that depends on one man's mood is just a press release.
American Democrats have a part in this too. Congress has largely watched as a president and his family's associates conduct foreign policy as private negotiation. Oversight on whether these envoys hold financial stakes in the outcome is not a partisan stunt. It's the minimum for a republic.
Peace is worth wanting. But the people of Ukraine, who have buried their sons and daughters to keep their country, deserve a settlement written with them and the democracies standing beside them, not delivered to them from a summit of the three powers that most want to redraw borders. Europe can still decide not to be on the menu. Thursday is the time to show it.


