Strip away the headline and the number that matters is 68.25. Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix produced that share of KOSPI companies' combined operating profit over nine months, and 66.45% of net profit. The index is hundreds of companies. The profits belong to two.
The quarter-on-quarter dip in net profit is noise, and nobody should build a theory on it. The concentration is the story, and it should unsettle a government that came to power promising broad-based renewal.
President Lee Jae-myung's Democratic Party has made a rising KOSPI a signature goal, with its 'KOSPI 5000' pledge and its corporate-governance overhaul. Shareholder protections and an end to the 'Korea discount' are worthy aims. Chaebol families have treated minority investors as an afterthought for decades, and the Left was right to say so. But a stock index is a scoreboard, not an economy. If two firms riding a global AI memory boom supply two-thirds of the profit, a rising KOSPI tells you almost nothing about whether the delivery driver, the subcontractor's welder or the retired woman collecting paper for pocket money is doing better. South Korea's elderly poverty rate is the worst in the OECD. No chip cycle has fixed that.
And it is a cycle. Memory is among the most volatile businesses on earth. Samsung's own chip division was bleeding money not long ago, in the 2023 downturn. A national strategy that depends on high-bandwidth memory demand staying red-hot is a leveraged bet, and it is being sold as prosperity. When the cycle turns, the pain will not be spread in proportion to the gains. It never is. Contract workers, suppliers squeezed on unit prices and regional economies built around a single plant will absorb the downturn, while the biggest shareholders sit on the upside they already booked.
That points to the harder question the Left should be asking: who gets paid when these two companies do? Dividends flow to shareholders, a group that is wealthy, foreign or both. Wages in the broader economy have not tracked the windfall. Smaller manufacturers that supply the giants have long complained that big buyers dictate terms and keep the margin for themselves. Labor reforms like the so-called Yellow Envelope Law, which lets subcontracted workers bargain with the firms that really control their pay, are exactly the right instinct. They deserve defending against the predictable chorus warning that any change will scare off capital.
My own side needs to be honest about its temptation. A Democratic government that measures success by index milestones will drift toward governing for the investor class and calling it national pride. It will be tempting to hand Samsung and SK Hynix whatever they ask for, whether subsidies, power, tax breaks or regulatory patience, because they are carrying the scoreboard. The public is entitled to ask for something back. If the state is underwriting the infrastructure, the electricity and the talent pipeline that make the chip boom possible, then the public should share in the returns through a windfall levy, a sovereign wealth mechanism, stronger pension holdings or binding supplier-pricing rules. Call it what it is, a return on public investment, not an attack on success.
The conservative reply is predictable and not stupid: these firms compete globally, taxes drive investment abroad, and a booming chip sector lifts everyone through jobs and exports. Some of that is true. But 'the tide lifts all boats' is a claim to be tested with wages, household debt and old-age poverty. Those measures do not look like a country that is sharing a boom.
Korea has one extraordinary industrial success story. The test of the Left is whether it can turn that success into a broad middle-class and pension-secure future, or whether it will celebrate record profits in two companies while everyone else is told to be grateful.
How it may affect me
If you hold Korean equities or index funds, your returns are heavily tied to just two chipmakers, so a memory downturn would hit your portfolio hard. The same goes for the National Pension Service, a major shareholder in both firms, so retirement income for ordinary Koreans is more exposed to the chip cycle than the 'broad market' label suggests.


