Warren Buffett donates $5.5 billion in Berkshire shares

Illustration for: Warren Buffett donates $5.5 billion in Berkshire shares
AI-generated illustration. Visual interpretation does not represent real individuals or scenes.

THE BARE STORY

Warren Buffett has donated approximately $5.5 billion in Berkshire Hathaway shares to four charitable foundations, increasing his annual contribution from the previous year.

The recipients are the Susan Thompson Buffett Foundation, the Sherwood Foundation, the Howard G. Buffett Foundation and the NoVo Foundation. The latter three are managed by Buffett’s children.

In a Thanksgiving message, Buffett urged people to show kindness and thank those who have helped them. He also reaffirmed his plan to give his remaining Berkshire holdings, valued at an estimated $162 billion, to the four foundations.

Buffett, 96, stepped down as Berkshire’s chairman in September.

Same Facts. One Perspective.

One viewpoint on the same facts.

Warren Buffett is, by the standards of his class, a good man. He lives in the same Omaha house he bought in 1958. He gives his money away. He has spent years saying publicly that the tax system he thrived in is rigged in favor of people like him. Which is exactly why his latest gift deserves a harder look than the Thanksgiving-card coverage will give it.

The headline number is $5.5 billion, handed to four foundations, three run by his children. Another $162 billion is promised to the same four. Give him credit for generosity. But look at what the arrangement is: one of the largest transfers of private wealth in human history, steered by a handful of people nobody elected, accountable to nobody, answering to a 96-year-old's family tree.

Start with the tax angle, because Buffett himself taught us to. He once noted that he paid a lower rate than his secretary. The reason is simple. His fortune is overwhelmingly unrealized gains in a company that pays no dividend. That wealth has been compounding for decades without being taxed, and donating the shares means those gains never will be. A nurse's paycheck is taxed the week she earns it. Buffett's fortune is taxed never, and we are asked to applaud as it flows tax-free into private control. Even at current capital gains rates, the forgone revenue on $162 billion would be in the tens of billions, enough to matter to a real school system or a real public health agency.

That's the quiet scandal of American philanthropy. The public subsidizes it through the tax code, and then the donor, not the public, decides what the money is for. The rest of us get a vote on schools, clinics and farm policy every other November. Buffett's heirs get one on the whole portfolio, permanently.

And they will use it. The Susan Thompson Buffett Foundation has been among the most important funders of contraception and abortion access in the country. After Dobbs, that is a lifeline for women in a dozen states. It is also an indictment. Reproductive freedom in America now depends partly on the continued goodwill and good judgment of one billionaire family, because the democratic process was captured by people who want to take it away. Liberals shouldn't celebrate that dependence. We should be furious that it exists.

The other foundations show the same problem from different angles: education in Omaha, agriculture and conflict zones, women's programs. Some of it is thoughtful and some of it is surely wasted, which is the point. Nobody outside the family gets to say which. NoVo, for one, has drawn criticism over how it treats the grassroots groups that depended on it. When your funder is also your only regulator, a change of heart is a change of policy.

Notice, too, that Buffett quietly abandoned the Gates Foundation, the institution he once called the vehicle for his fortune. Even the world's most admired philanthropist changed the destination of tens of billions of dollars because of personal circumstances. That's what private governance looks like: gentle, well-meaning and arbitrary.

The Right will say it's his money and the alternative is Washington waste. But it was never only his. It grew inside an American legal order, protected by American courts, enriched by American consumers and a stock market the public made possible. A society that lets a fortune escape taxation and then thanks the owner for spending it is not generous. It is deferential.

Buffett's kindness is real. Give thanks for it, as he asks. But a country should not need to hope its richest citizens turn out to be kind. It should tax unrealized gains at death or sooner, close the loopholes that let private foundations become dynastic power centers, and fund what matters with public money under public rules. The best billionaire in America is making the case against billionaires without ever saying so.

Read the story at

Note: All TheBareNews content is AI-generated. For additional context, reporting, and updates, you are invited to explore the news outlets linked above.

Stories You May Have Missed